The U.S. Department of Labor’s Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) recently announced a preliminary list of the top 10 most frequently cited workplace safety violations for 2012 (needless to say, as 2012 isn’t quite over yet, the list isn’t completely final, but it’s surely close).
OSHA’s top 10 most frequently cited workplace safety violations for 2012 are as follows:
1. Fall Protection – 7,250 total violations – this includes failure to protect open sides and edges, failure to prevent falls from a roof, failure to cover holes or excavation areas such as a well, pit, shaft, or similar excavation of 6 feet or more in depth. Proper guardrail systems, fences, barricades, or covers should be in place.
2. Hazard Communication – 4,696 total violations – this relates to the failure to provide adequate education and training programs, signage, labels on containers of hazardous materials, and safety data information.
3. Scaffolding – 3,814 total violations – Scaffolding topped OSHA’s list in 2011, but still remains high up on the list in 2012. Violations involving scaffolding pertain to scaffold construction, and use of protective guardrails, safety nets or other safety precautions, and violations pertaining to proper access to scaffolding.
4. Respiratory Protection – 2,371 total violations – respiratory protection violations include unsuitable respirators–either due to sizing/fit or inadequate function, and lack of procedures or training for how to use respirators.
5. Ladders – 2,310 total violations – this includes improper use of ladders (e.g., standing on the top step), use of an improper ladder for a particular job and allowing excessive loads on ladders.
6. Machine Guarding – 2,097 total violations – this includes improper placement or inadequate anchoring for fixed machinery, or improper and unsafe exposures at the point-of-operation (e.g., unsafe exposure to machine blades)
7. Powered Industrial Trucks – 1,993 total violations – violations here include lack of proper repair and upkeep of vehicles to ensure safety; lack of proper training for operators–or refresher training as needed/required.
8. Electrical Wiring – 1,744 total violations – this includes everything from improper use of extension cords to use of temporary wiring instead of permanent wiring.
9. Lockout/Tagout – 1,572 total violations – this one was number five on OSHA’s list for 2011; it includes violations that occur due to lack of training and inspections for the servicing and maintenance of machines and equipment in which the unexpected start up of the machines or equipment, or release of stored energy, could harm employees.
10. Electrical (General) – 1,332 total violations – general electrical violations include instances of electrical shock or electrocution.
If a company pays to have private ambulances and paramedics on-site at its warehouse facility on hot days, does that tell you something?
I don’t know about you, but if I’m working there, it would tell me that there’s an added element of risk to my workday. Risk of things like heat exhaustion, heat stroke, heat cramps, heat rash…particularly, if I’m working at an Amazon.com warehouse where working conditions include long hours (8-12 hour days, sometimes with mandatory overtime) and, according to an Amazon.com Warehouse Associate-Picker job posting, I’m lifting up to 49 lbs of merchandise at a time.
Such conditions were the focus of a recent expose done by The Morning Call‘s Spencer Soper. The Morning Call interviewed a total of twenty current and former Amazon.com warehouse workers on working conditions at Amazon’s Breinigsville, PA warehouse. What Soper found out was a bit disturbing.
The worker allegations included accounts of:
Sounds like an employer-of-choice to me.
Being a bit jaded, I went over to Glassdoor.com to check out the employee (staff and contract) reviews of work life at Amazon.com. I scanned the warehouse- and distribution-related entries and found that the PA warehouse was not just a bunch of disgruntled workers—such gripes are seemingly pervasive at Amazon.com: Long hours. Pressure to make rate. Micro-managing. Mandatory overtime. Points. Continual churn of contract or temp workers who seek full-time status, but never get it.
So much for the “fun” work environment that Amazon’s (or actually, Integrity Staffing Solutions) job postings tout.
Needless to say, some Amazon workers had made complaints to OSHA. And, in fairness, according to The Morning Call article, Amazon’s Allen Forney—the PA site safety manager—has also reported to OSHA the heat-related incidents and how Amazon has responded to such incidents on days of excessive heat.
Forney stated in a letter to OSHA (6/13/11) that on 6/3/11, six “employees were treated at a local hospital ER for non-work related medical conditions triggered by the heat” (note the “non-work related”…CYA all the way). Of course, OSHA does require that employers must “Notify OSHA within 8 hours of a workplace incident in which there is a death or when three or more workers go to a hospital.”
Forney also notes that Amazon has put in place measures such as adding fans; installing heat index sensors in March that alert managers when the index rises above 90 degrees; and purchasing ‘2,000 cooling bandannas’ and cooling vests for workers. Managers also ‘walk the building’ to ensure workers get enough water. And, when the temperature is between 90 and 99 degrees, workers get an additional five minutes of break time; if the temp hits 100 to 114 degrees, workers ‘typically’ get a five-minute break every hour, and ‘heavier work’ gets moved to cooler times during the day. Gee, thanks.
Of note, it has to get to 115 degrees before, according to Forney, “the senior manager on duty will decide whether to close down the entire shift.” Yes, 115 degrees.
For the record, as fans seem to be a big part of the heat index management plan at Amazon.com, a quick visit over to the CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) provided this regarding use of fans for heat-related symptoms:
Electric fans may provide comfort, but when the temperature is in the high 90s, fans will not prevent heat-related illness. Taking a cool shower or bath or moving to an air-conditioned place is a much better way to cool off. Air conditioning is the strongest protective factor against heat-related illness. Exposure to air conditioning for even a few hours a day will reduce the risk for heat-related illness. Consider visiting a shopping mall or public library for a few hours.
The inclusion of OSHA in all this begs the question, “so what did OSHA do about it?”
OSHA issued recommendations. OSHA recommended that Amazon reduce warehouse temperatures and humidity, but OSHA did not provide the temperature at which the warehouse should be maintained. OSHA also recommended hourly breaks in a cool area, and informing workers and
supervisors of the actual heat index or temperature in order for them to increase
monitoring as it gets hotter, and to provide personal fans at each work station. (Didn’t I just quote the CDC as saying fans wouldn’t help in preventing heat-related illness? Go figure.)
So OSHA falls short of actually putting a stake in the ground as to what temperature is acceptable for safe working conditions—and as a result, I can’t help but put a little blame on OSHA’s shoulders. If you only follow what you’re being mandated to do, well… But common sense at the very least should prevail over at Amazon.com. When you need to hire ambulances and paramedics and park them right outside your warehouse (next the the break truck?)—that should tell you something. Likewise, when workers are passing out or leaving to go home or being carted off the the hospital, it should tell you something.
And in the interim, I have something to tell Amazon.com—that lovely air conditioning unit shown above cools up to a 4,000 square foot area—and it’s available on your own damn site for $8,295.