UnumProvident settles with Two States

New York, NYUnumProvident Corp. has settled major lawsuits in the states of New York and California.

In the first lawsuit, New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer announced on November 1 that the UnumProvident will stop contingent commission payments, disclose insurance-broker compensation and pay a settlement of $17.4 million.

Of that $17.4 million, $15.5 million will go to restitution for policy holders and $1.9 million will pay for a civil penalty.

The agreement makes UnumProvident the first disability carrier to stop paying contingent commissions on all group insurance products.

Contingent commissions are offered by insurance companies to brokers who push clients to their companies but the result is that clients may not get the best prices for their insurance. UnumProvident paid commissions to brokers who renewed policies despite rate increases.

A similar lawsuit, filed by state insurance regulators last year, was also settled in California this month. UnumProvident Corp agreed to give prospective policy holders more information about broker commissions.

However, in the California lawsuit, no money will change hands. Rather, the company must provide its clients with information about broker compensation and must also show how commissions affect premium prices. This information is to be given before customers agree to purchase the insurance.

Among the terms of the California settlement:

• When a customer requests employee benefits coverage, that customer will be provided with information concerning standards payable and other compensation for the broker.
  
  
• UnumProvident will sever all existing loan relationships with brokers and will not enter into new financial relationships with insurance brokers.
  
  
• UnumProvident is no longer able to sponsor broker production awards programs which provide compensation to brokers for selling UnumProvident insurance.

The California lawsuit was part of a campaign coordinated with NY Attorney General Eliot Spitzer in an attempt to force insurance companies to be more forthright with their customers.